Virtual Receptionist vs. AI vs. Hiring: True Cost Comparison
Answering every call matters—but what's the most cost-effective way? A detailed breakdown of your options.
You know you need to answer every call. The question is how. Your three main options: hire someone, use a virtual receptionist service, or deploy AI. Each has different costs, capabilities, and trade-offs.
Let's break down the true cost of each option so you can make an informed decision.
Option 1: Hire an In-House Receptionist
The traditional approach—a dedicated person answering your phones:
- Salary: $32,000-$45,000/year depending on location
- Benefits: Add 20-30% for health, PTO, payroll taxes
- Training: 2-4 weeks before they're fully effective
- Coverage: 8 hours/day, 5 days/week (you're still missing calls)
- Turnover: Average receptionist stays 1-2 years
True annual cost: $40,000-$60,000
Best for: Companies doing $1M+ revenue that need full-time office presence and can afford the overhead.
Option 2: Virtual Receptionist Service
Human receptionists, but outsourced:
- Monthly fee: $200-$500 for base plans
- Per-minute charges: $0.75-$1.50 for time beyond base
- Setup fees: $50-$200 one-time
- After-hours: Often extra or limited
- Training limitations: They handle dozens of clients—your business isn't their priority
True annual cost: $4,000-$10,000 depending on call volume
Best for: Businesses that want human touch but can't afford full-time staff. Works best for simple call handling—struggles with complex scheduling or technical questions.
Option 3: AI Phone Answering
Modern AI that handles calls automatically:
- Monthly fee: $100-$300 typically
- Per-minute charges: Often included or very low
- 24/7 coverage: No extra charge for after-hours
- Instant answers: No hold time, no waiting for callbacks
- Consistent: Same quality on call 1 and call 100
- Learning: Gets better at your specific business over time
True annual cost: $1,200-$4,000
Best for: Businesses that want 24/7 coverage, consistent handling, and cost efficiency. Modern AI handles booking, FAQs, and qualification very well.
“I used a virtual receptionist for two years. Great people, but they'd mess up technical questions and couldn't access my schedule in real-time. The AI costs 70% less and books appointments directly into my calendar.”
Side-by-Side Comparison
Annual Cost
- In-House: $40,000-$60,000
- Virtual Receptionist: $4,000-$10,000
- AI: $1,200-$4,000
24/7 Coverage
- In-House: No (additional cost)
- Virtual Receptionist: Limited/extra cost
- AI: Yes, included
Booking Capability
- In-House: Yes, with training
- Virtual Receptionist: Basic only
- AI: Yes, real-time calendar access
Scalability
- In-House: Limited by human capacity
- Virtual Receptionist: Scales with cost
- AI: Unlimited simultaneous calls
See AI in Action
Try Local Business Pro's AI phone answering and see why contractors are switching from traditional options.
Request DemoThe Hybrid Approach
Many successful businesses combine options:
- AI handles after-hours, weekends, and overflow
- Human staff handles complex calls and high-value customers during business hours
- AI qualifies leads before passing to humans
Making the Decision
Questions to ask yourself:
- What's my call volume? (High volume = AI efficiency shines)
- How complex are my calls? (Simple booking = AI wins; complex technical = human may be needed)
- What hours do I need coverage? (After-hours critical = AI or expensive alternatives)
- What's my budget? (Under $5K/year = AI is the only real option)
The Bottom Line
For most service businesses under $1M revenue, AI phone answering offers the best combination of cost, capability, and coverage. It's not about replacing humans—it's about having consistent, affordable call handling that ensures no opportunity is missed.
The math is simple: if AI saves you even 5 missed calls per month at an average job value of $300, it pays for itself 5x over.
About Local Business Pro Team
The Local Business Pro team combines decades of experience in service businesses, technology, and customer success to create content that helps contractors grow.
View full profile →